ANALYSIS OF THE BRP VS ARCTIC CAT LAWSUIT
Its been a pretty busy couple weeks for powersports industry leader BRP. Only days ago the company announced the mothballing of the legendary Evinrude outboard engine brand.
Hot on the heels of this negative news comes a very impressive legal win in a battle between BRP's industry leading snowmobile brand, Ski-Doo, and Textron’s recently acquired Arctic Cat snowmobile brand.
THE REV AND THE PYRAMID
In 2002 Ski-Doo introduced a new snowmobile chassis design that literally changed the way a snowmobile was ridden. It's design and ergonomics were referred to as "rider forward". The new chassis configuration was unlike anything seen in the industry and closely mirrored the ergonomic orientation of an off-road motorcycle.
A large portion of the re-configuring of the chassis was rooted in what is called a "pyramidal frame". Because the rider is oriented forward on the REV chassis (compared to all conventional snowmobiles before it) a new over-structure had to be developed to increase frame stiffness while accommodating a radically re-positioned rider’s perch.
BRP applied for and was granted patents surrounding, not only the pyramidal frame, but many other aspects of what is referred to as the “REV” platform.
FAST FORWARD TO 2008
In 2008 and later in 2012, Arctic Cat introduced snowmobiles using what looked very similar to a pyramidal frame. We will not argue if this was or wasn't an infringement on Ski-Doo’s patents.
The issue has been litigated in both the US and Canada on more than one occasion and from what we hear, Arctic Cat won the issue against Ski-Doo’s assertion of infringement in the US and in Canada earlier this decade.
As of this week and beginning in July this year Arctic Cat is not only forbidden to sell but in some cryptic way is not allowed to use any snowmobiles affected by the award granted from the Canadian Federal Court.
Does this mean Arctic Cat snowmobile owners are contravening some legal statute when they head out for a ride this coming winter? Dunno.
SHOW THEM THE MONEY
On top of this ruling is an order for Arctic Cat (Textron) to pay BRP $135.00 for each and every Arctic Cat snowmobile manufactured since 2008 using the pyramidal frame design. Get out your calculator. That's a big number in our world but maybe not so much in the corporate realm.
If you assume there have potentially been 100,000 Arctic Cat sleds built since 2008 using the pyramidal frame design, the number is not chicken feed (Cat food?). Here’s one number I guarantee is large in anyone's world: The legal costs incurred by both parties to launch and to defend this action.
There are some profoundly intriguing questions surrounding this issue. First, the ruling is only enforceable in Canada. Does this mean Arctic Cat must stop selling sleds in Canada until a deal is struck with BRP? A deal? Yes, a deal. We haven't heard a fat lady singing so look for something which sounds like a compromise.
Sea-Doo lost a watercraft patent suit (seriously, a decades old watercraft patent) with Arctic Cat some time ago. It amounted to tens of millions of dollars being owed to Arctic Cat. We wonder - is that number still on the "accounts receivable" chart at Arctic Cat?
WILL THIS IMPACT YAMAHA
Wouldn't you like to be a fly on the wall at Yamaha's snowmobile division HQ in Markham, Ontario, Canada? Will there be implications for Yamaha as a result of the use of the same pyramidal frame design in play on virtually all the sleds Arctic Cat builds for Yamaha? As of this writing there is no mention of Yamaha in this action. We think that's good.
One might wonder what Textron is thinking about this jackpot. Even if the award and ruling is negotiated down there’s still staggering legal costs that often dwarf the actual settlement numbers. Textron has had to navigate this issue without ever being involved in the actual design of these sleds.
Here's one more. Arctic Cat is no doubt working on the next generation of its ProCross chassis to take to market in the not too distant future. If this is true we can’t help but wonder if any new and under-wraps designs have continued to use the pyramidal frame design.
We don't know the answers to most of these questions but you can be sure somebody does. Stay tuned.
More Like This
LATEST VIDEOS View All
Snowmobiling Algoma Country PART 2
January 21, 2021
In part 2 of our special Northern Ontario snowmobile destination ride. Luke and his good buddy ...
2021 Polaris Indy 650 MATRYX VR1 Review
January 20, 2021
Motorhead Mark presents his impressions of the 2021 Polaris Indy MATRYX VR1 featuring the ...
Snowmobiling Algoma Country in Northern Ontario
January 14, 2021
In a special two-episode Northern Ontario snowmobile destination ride, Luke is joined with ...
2021 Polaris 850 Switchback Assault 146 Review
January 13, 2021
In this TEST RIDE AJ evaluates the 2021 Polaris Switchback Assault 146 in the all-new MATRYX ...
Snowmobiling in New York: Hamilton County / Adirondacks
January 7, 2021
Matt Lester and his daughter Madeline take an epic father/daughter adventure to Hamilton County ...
Top Gear View All
January 18, 2021
IPONE MAINTENANCE & CARE LINE
Getting the most out of your snowmobile requires a lot more than just topping up the oil reservoir whenever you go for a ride.
Ask Motorhead View All
November 15, 2020
600 EFI, 600 ETEC or 900 ACE?
Mark takes a look at which of these sleds is right for a reader...
Press Releases View All
January 20, 2021
2021 KLIM Frozen Cow Tag Snowbike Ride
Join KLIM, Timbersled, Rever and Trail Tech for the third annual snowbike ride in the rugged Idaho mountains on March 20, 2021.
Tourism View All
November 1, 2020
5-STAR SLEDDING IN CHARLEVOIX
Rarely does a specific hotel earn universal recognition as a must-visit snowmobiling destination...